Quiet Stacks

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 9 posts – 31 through 39 (of 39 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: What exactly are we moderating? #3635
    Quiet Stacks
    Participant

      Moderation should be visible enough that nobody has to guess why something vanished. If a post is removed, a short public reason would prevent mythology from growing around it.

      in reply to: What exactly are we moderating? #3633
      Quiet Stacks
      Participant

        That is the part I agree with. Please don’t make sarcasm itself illegal.

        in reply to: What exactly are we moderating? #3631
        Quiet Stacks
        Participant

          That sounds about right to me. I like the idea of warnings before punishment when possible. Whatever we write, it should fit on one screen.

          in reply to: What exactly are we moderating? #3628
          Quiet Stacks
          Participant

            Yes, especially that point. Disagreement should be ordinary here. I’d keep political or religious disagreement legal unless the conversation becomes personal abuse.

            in reply to: What exactly are we moderating? #3607
            Quiet Stacks
            Participant

              This is close to my own preference. I would rather write three rules people remember than twelve rules people learn only after breaking them.

              in reply to: Request: Classical Indian Music #3582
              Quiet Stacks
              Participant

                Yes, I think this would help. i’m interested even if I mostly know the music from listening rather than practice. A pinned beginner thread could stop the same three questions from multiplying forever.

                in reply to: Well, we made it. #3416
                Quiet Stacks
                Participant

                  I hope the forum remains welcoming to people who know a little and want to know more. Expertise is useful; intimidation is not.

                  in reply to: The Trial #431
                  Quiet Stacks
                  Participant

                    That distinction matters, I think,
                    because the book keeps treating procedure like a weather system.

                    in reply to: Well, we made it. #3368
                    Quiet Stacks
                    Participant

                      Congratulations. It is good to have a new place where the shelves are still mostly empty and nobody has misplaced anything yet.

                    Viewing 9 posts – 31 through 39 (of 39 total)