Wooden dummy in an unheated garage through winter?

Home Forums China Kung Fu, Martial Arts and Chi Gong Wooden dummy in an unheated garage through winter?

Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #51
      Wing Chun Wrench
      Participant

        Anyone kept a wooden dummy in an unheated garage through a Canadian winter?

        Mine is in the garage now. Humidity isn’t bad but temperature swings obviously are. I’m less worried about it being pretty than the body splitting or the arms swelling enough to become a pain.

        Actual experience preferred.

      • #1518
        Adam Guitar Shruti
        Participant

          I have not kept one through a Canadian winter, but I would be cautious about the seasonal cycle more than the cold alone. Have you measured the humidity in the garage when the temperature drops, and is the dummy finished with lacquer or just bare wood?

          • #1519
            Paws
            Participant

              Yeah, I’d worry more about the dry air and sudden thaw than the cold itself. If the garage swings a lot, the joints and arms can loosen up or get stubborn, which is annoying in a very specific, martial-arts way.

              • #1520
                Warehouse Groove
                Participant

                  my buddy left his out in a shed and the arms got all weird after one winter. not broken, just enough to make him swear at it lol

              • #1523
                Paws
                Participant

                  If the dummy starts complaining in winter, I expect mine to too. At least it is quieter than a dog pretending the vacuum is a predator.

                  • #1532
                    Warehouse Groove
                    Participant

                      lol yeah mine was louder than my shift manager

                  • #1528
                    Ritual-Notes
                    Participant

                      that sounds like the start of a very expensive piece of furniture

                      hope it stays intact…

                  • #182
                    Footwork 63
                    Participant

                      Keep the dummy steady and do not let the garage become a second weather system. I would check the wood, mount and arms before every session once the temperature starts moving around.

                      A training tool is not improved by forcing it to prove your toughness.

                    • #1521
                      Ritual-Notes
                      Participant

                        I would not assume the winter itself is the main issue here the bigger problem is usually repeated expansion and contraction in a dry garage. If the dummy is solid stock and the joints are not already loose I think it may survive better than people expect

                        • #1522
                          Adam Guitar Shruti
                          Participant

                            That is useful, thank you. Do you mean a solid body with the common pinned arms, or one of the lighter practice dummies with more assembled parts? I ask because the response may differ quite a bit depending on how the joints are made.

                            Even a modest amount…

                          • #1524
                            Adam Guitar Shruti
                            Participant

                              That makes sense, and I suspect the construction matters more than the headline temperature. Are the arms wedged in tightly, or do they already have a little play when the weather changes? If there is a meaningful fit issue now, winter might only make it more obvious rather than causing a new problem.

                              I would also be curious whether the garage is uninsulated enough to get condensation on the wood. That seems like the sort of detail that decides whether this is merely inconvenient or genuinely damaging.

                              • #1526
                                Ritual-Notes
                                Participant

                                  Right and if the arms have a little play now that may be the dummy equivalent of a joint cracking on a cold morning. Not a catastrophe just the thing that makes practice feel like you are arguing with furniture

                              • #1527
                                Paws
                                Participant

                                  Dry garage wood is basically a cranky houseplant with punches.

                                  Still cheaper than replacing it later, probably.

                                  • #1530
                                    Adam Guitar Shruti
                                    Participant

                                      Yes, that is the practical distinction I was trying to make. A bit of movement or seasonal tightening sounds like a maintenance issue, not necessarily a failure, whereas actual checking at the grain lines would be another matter entirely. I would still avoid anything that traps moisture against the body.

                                      If the garage is very dry, perhaps a cover that breathes would be safer than wrapping it tightly.

                                • #215

                                  The dummy should be treated like a wooden instrument, not an indoor appliance. Stable temperature, air around it and no forcing swollen parts are the basic rules.

                                  Also, a form can look perfect in a video because the camera is not trying to hit you. That is a different kind of room tone.

                                • #137
                                  Wrench And Jab
                                  Participant

                                    If the dummy is solid wood, let it live in the garage instead of moving it in and out every day. Big changes are worse than a steady cold room. Keep it off the floor, check the mounting and do not force a swollen arm through the hole.

                                    That last part sounds obvious until somebody has already decided the wood is supposed to obey him.

                                  • #1525
                                    Paws
                                    Participant

                                      sounds risky tbh

                                    • #228
                                      Pipe And Punch
                                      Participant

                                        Keep it off the concrete and do not force the arms if the wood swells. I would rather see a dummy with a little seasonal movement than one that got cracked because somebody wanted it perfect.

                                        Forms are useful for drilling a movement. They do not replace somebody trying to take your head off.

                                      • #192
                                        Wire And Gloves
                                        Participant

                                          Keep the dummy off the concrete and do not move it between a cold garage and a warm room every day. Check the mount and the arms when the weather changes. Wood will tell you if it is unhappy, usually after you have ignored it for a while.

                                          I would not put oil on it just because somebody on a video said oil means maintenance.

                                        • #120
                                          Ringside And Rescue
                                          Participant

                                            I have not stored a wooden dummy through a Canadian winter, but I have seen plenty of wood split after people treated a garage like a climate-controlled room. Keep it off concrete, give it air on all sides and do not move it straight from cold into a hot room and start training.

                                            The temperature swing is the problem as much as the low temperature. Check the joints and arms when the seasons change. Wood does not care how confident the owner is.

                                          • #225
                                            Tai-Texas
                                            Participant

                                              The dummy can teach alignment and coordination, but it cannot be the whole proof of a style. In school work I see the same thing when people confuse a polished procedure with understanding what happens when conditions change.

                                              Keep it stable, train the movement honestly and test the idea with a partner when appropriate. The form is a tool, not a credential.

                                            • #1529
                                              Warehouse Groove
                                              Participant

                                                mine warped a little in a storage unit once.

                                                not tragic but annoying as hell

                                                • #1531
                                                  Paws
                                                  Participant

                                                    Good call on the cover. Leave it dressed like a wrestler, not a sandwich.

                                              Viewing 11 reply threads
                                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.