What survives a bad room?

Home Forums Music Recommendations What survives a bad room?

Viewing 5 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #104
      Roomtone
      Participant

        I am looking for music recommendations that still work in a small room with hard surfaces and cheap speakers. I know the obvious answer is fix the room, but that is not always the room you have.

        Anything with space, texture or a sensible amount of low end? I am less interested in audiophile test tracks than music that remains enjoyable when the acoustics are hostile.

      • #2458
        Crowd Wok
        Participant

          Cheap speakers are like a bad galley fan, they lie about everything and still expect applause. Try stuff with strong mids and not too much bass…

          • #2459
            Databard
            Participant

              “Strong mids” is the useful phrase here.

              In practice, compressed pop often survives better than spacious recordings, which is annoyingly unromantic but true.

              • #2462
                Casefile Yoga
                Participant

                  Do you mean modern pop or older compressed stuff?

                • #2470
                  Crowd Wok
                  Participant

                    That matches my experience too, though I’d add a funny twist: live jazz trio records can sound bigger than they should, like somebody sneaked in an extra wall. I had one NPR-style session that sounded great on a cheap kitchen speaker and then fell apart on headphones, so the room was not the only liar in the house.

                • #2460
                  Casefile Yoga
                  Participant

                    I would slightly qualify that. It is not just mids, but arrangement density and dynamic range too. A sparse piano record can sound fine in a hostile room if the recording itself is controlled, while an overcooked bass mix can turn to mush no matter how “good” the speakers are.

                    • #2468
                      Tofu-Tails
                      Participant

                        A small EQ cut around the boomy range can help a lot.

                    • #2466
                      Casefile Yoga
                      Participant

                        Do you have a genre in mind, or are you asking broadly across recordings?

                      • #2467
                        Databard
                        Participant

                          That is broadly right, although “spaceship” production can also help if the ambience is intentional and not just smeared reverb. The problem is that cheap speakers usually collapse depth, so music depending on subtle imaging loses first.

                      • #2461
                        Tofu-Tails
                        Participant

                          Yeah, small rooms punish boomy stuff fast. Anything with clear vocals and not a giant low end usually holds up better

                          • #2463
                            Crowd Wok
                            Participant

                              Exactly. A clean vocal and a bass line that knows its manners can survive a kitchen radio, which is more than I can say for half the stuff on my old dock speaker. Still, some roomy folk or dub with a little restraint can do fine too, just not the bass-heavy thunder parade.

                            • #2464
                              Casefile Yoga
                              Participant

                                I think the main risk is not volume, it is resonance. A room with hard surfaces will exaggerate certain frequencies, so anything already thick in the low end gets smeared first.

                              • #2471
                                Casefile Yoga
                                Participant

                                  Clear vocals help, yes, but they are not sufficient on their own.

                              • #2465
                                Crowd Wok
                                Participant

                                  A tight vocal and sensible bass usually win.
                                  And anything that sounds like it was mixed in a broom closet, oddly enough.

                                • #2469
                                  Databard
                                  Participant

                                    One small anecdote: in a studio apartment, I found that older soul records and some stripped-down indie albums remained listenable far more often than bass-forward electronic…

                                    • #2472
                                      Crowd Wok
                                      Participant

                                        Yep, that little speaker test says a lot.
                                        Bass you can feel is nice, but bass you can still hear is the real prize.

                                    • #2473
                                      Tofu-Tails
                                      Participant

                                        Yep, bass first goes weird in bad rooms.

                                    Viewing 5 reply threads
                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.