Original or XL if I mostly brew one mug?

Home Forums coffee? Tea? Manual Coffee Dial-In & Specialty Bean Discovery Original or XL if I mostly brew one mug?

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #5013
      Okra
      Participant
        Brewer and filter: AeroPress XL; AeroPress XL paper
        Grinder, burr and calibration: Timemore Sculptor 078; 078 turbo burrs; setting 8; touch point checked
        Bean, roaster, process and roast date: washed Ethiopia Guji; Passenger Coffee; washed; roast date 2026-08-18
        Dose and water mass: 18.0 g coffee; 279 g water
        Temperature and water profile: 91°C; bottled low-mineral water, about 45 ppm TDS
        Pour/agitation schedule: 63 g bloom for 40 s, then three pours; no stirring after bloom
        Drawdown time: 3:05
        Expected and perceived flavour: expected clean citrus and tea-like finish; perceived cup is bitter in the finish
        Changes already tested: changed filter paper and repeated the same recipe

        This is a real purchase question, not an invitation to name every product in the category. I care about the workflow in the title and would love reports from people who lived with both options.

      • #5014
        Okra
        Participant

          Owned both for more than six months. The difference that survived the honeymoon was workflow, not cup quality. One is easier to repeat when half awake; the other gives more room to fiddle. I kept the simpler one.

          • #5015
            Radiorook
            Participant

              Used both daily, not just side by side for a weekend. If you value fast setup I would pick the first; if you enjoy adjusting every variable the second earns its extra fuss. Neither made bad beans interesting.

              • #5018
                Arcade-Afterdark
                Participant

                  I came here for a simple answer and now I own a spreadsheet. excellent

            • #5016
              Wok-Dough
              Participant

                I only own one of the two, so weight this below the dual-owner reports. Mine has been consistent and easy to clean, but I cannot tell you whether the other one would be better in the same kitchen.

              • #5017
                Dhrupad Notes
                Participant

                  I only own one of the two, so weight this below the dual-owner reports. Mine has been consistent and easy to clean, but I cannot tell you whether the other one would be better in the same kitchen.

                • #5019
                  Okra
                  Participant

                    The important constraint here is counter space. The technically better option is not better if it lives in a cupboard.

                    • #5020
                      Radiorook
                      Participant

                        The important constraint here is counter space. The technically better option is not better if it lives in a cupboard.

                  Viewing 4 reply threads
                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.