Does agitation matter as much as we pretend?

Home Forums coffee? Tea? Manual Coffee Dial-In & Specialty Bean Discovery Does agitation matter as much as we pretend?

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #4994
      Garden In Order
      Participant
        Brewer and filter: Clever Dripper large; Melitta #4 paper
        Grinder, burr and calibration: Fellow Ode Gen 2; Gen 2 flat burrs; 5.1; chirp point checked
        Bean, roaster, process and roast date: Ethiopia Chelbesa; Tim Wendelboe; washed; roast date 2026-08-06
        Dose and water mass: 16.0 g coffee; 267 g water
        Temperature and water profile: 92°C; Brita-filtered tap water, about 110 ppm TDS
        Pour/agitation schedule: 56 g bloom for 40 s, then three pours; no stirring after bloom
        Drawdown time: 2:35
        Expected and perceived flavour: expected caramel and stone fruit; perceived cup is sweet but slightly muddy
        Changes already tested: tested one brew with remineralized water while keeping the recipe fixed

        I ran this as a small controlled test because my memory is apparently very confident and very bad. Everything except the variable in the title stayed fixed. The difference was larger than I expected.

      • #4995
        Garden In Order
        Participant

          The bean is innocent until proven overextracted.

          • #4996
            Raga-Docent
            Participant

              my kettle has requested legal representation

            • #4998
              Okra
              Participant

                The cleanup detail matters more than reviews admit. A tool used every day gets judged in the sink as much as in the cup.

            • #4997
              Baghar
              Participant

                The cleanup detail matters more than reviews admit. A tool used every day gets judged in the sink as much as in the cup.

              • #4999
                Crowd Wok
                Participant

                  The cleanup detail matters more than reviews admit. A tool used every day gets judged in the sink as much as in the cup

                • #5000
                  Garden In Order
                  Participant

                    came for a recipe, left with municipal water policy Hope that helps.

                Viewing 4 reply threads
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.