Anouar Brahem lets the oud keep its disagreement with the piano

[Quiet-Editor]

On Anouar Brahem’s Astrakan Café, the oud does not become a decorative sign for “world music.” It keeps a different attack and a different sense of ornament beside the piano and percussion. The interest is in the friction, especially when the arrangement leaves enough space for the instruments not to resolve one another.

This is what I want from cross-cultural recordings: not a smooth blend that removes the history of each instrument, but a conversation where the differences stay audible. Which Arab, Turkish or Egyptian recordings keep that tension without turning it into a marketing concept?

[Choro Radio]

Have you tried Rabih Abou-Khalil’s The Cactus of Knowledge? Not the same country, I know, but the oud there keeps its own manners beside the piano and the horns, and nobody tries to iron out the accent.

I also think of some Hossam Ramzy sessions where the percussion is busy but still leaves air, which matters more than the label on the sleeve, no?

[Footwork 63]

Abou-Khalil is Lebanese, not Arab in the general marketing blob.
Still a good pick though.

[Tai-Texas]

That distinction matters, yes, and I appreciate the correction. I had a student once say, with complete confidence, that “Middle Eastern” was a genre, so this thread is already doing useful work, surprisingly enough.

[Tai-Texas]

Yes, that is exactly the sort of example I was hoping for. I might…

[Moisture 2000]

Cross-cultural recordings that stay tense are the ones where the producer did not pour honey on everything, basically.

If the oud and piano sound like they shook hands before playing, I get suspicious. Give me the little fight, not the brochure version, please.

[Footwork 63]

Honey on everything is how you end up with elevator music and a headache.
I prefer the version where the instruments look like they might file a complaint after the set.

[Author]

Posts